When you support a team week after week, year after year, so many games are instantly forgotten. Classics are few and far between, but ahead of the international break, Cardiff served up two within a week. They may have let a three goal half-time lead slip against West Ham, but this was a game of the highest standard. Two very good teams giving it everything they have and Cardiff did not hand over the game, West Ham ripped it out of their grasp.
The 5-4 win against Burnley had everything and this time it was Cardiff eating away at a deficit and finding a glorious late winner deep into injury time. It was conclusive proof that Cardiff can trade blows with two recent Premier League sides and need not fear anyone at this level. They looked in good shape, despite an ever-increasing injury list and they were 14th in the table, which is where they should be according to their estimated wage bill. They were performing well during a daunting run of fixtures.
Rubin Colwill returned to the side during this period and he was instrumental in both games. Cardiff’s most naturally gifted player thrives in chaos and both games were frantic, end to end affairs. He had a great international break too, seizing on his opportunities and winning Man of the Match against Portugal. The problem is that his return appears to have also destabilised the team somewhat.
Embed from Getty ImagesJack Moylan has been a revelation since joining from Lincoln and has not only been Cardiff’s star performer, there is a case to be made that no one has performed better in the division thus far. As versatile as he is, filling in up top or drifting in from the left, he looks a natural number 10, which is traditionally where Colwill, a natural roamer, is usually stationed. The solution in recent weeks has been to play both there, but it leaves Cardiff with essentially five attackers and five defenders. Maybe you can pull that off at home, where teams tend to sit off you, but away from, when you will need to absorb pressure at times, Cardiff look porous and ill at ease.
Joel Colwill was the casualty of his brother’s return and he was in fine form, supporting Alex Robertson and driving the team forward from the heart of midfield. As much as Rubin has offered the team since returning, there is now a Joel-shaped hole in the team. Burnley poured through it at will and despite impressing early on against Norwich yesterday, they looked top heavy and vulnerable after the break.
That is the recurring theme of Cardiff’s away form this season. Brian Barry-Murphy has recorded a very impressive 21 home wins in his 31 games since taking charge and Cardiff are unbeaten at CCS this year, but they are yet to win away. Ahead of the Norwich game, Cardiff were first for expected goals in the whole division, but 20th for expected goals against, so it is clear where their deficiencies lie. With 27 goals scored and 27 conceded, that averaged out over a season equates to 46 points, which is what Leicester went down with last season, so improvement is clearly needed.
Embed from Getty ImagesA rotten run of defensive injuries has certainly not helped. Dylan Lawlor has hardly featured, Calum Chambers has not featured at all while Gabriel Osho and Perry Ng are both sidelined. Will Fish has just returned from a long-term lay off and is probably playing more than he should and Krystian Bielik is soldiering on. Having them all available would certainly help, but defending has not yet proven to be a Barry-Murphy strength. There is not a clear hierarchy between the centre backs, so rotation inevitably ensues and that does not allow bonds to form.
If you look at the make up of the squad, the ideal formation maybe what Leeds have been using to great effect, most recently in their hammering away at Chelsea. They lock rock solid with three centre backs, wing backs, two in central midfield, two attackers and a lone striker. With a fully fit squad to select from, that would present three of the five centre backs a game, could pair Joel Colwill with Robertson plus Rubin Colwill with Moylan. It would mean sacrificing wingers though, while Chris Willock and Ollie Tanner are currently both in the top 10 for most chances created in the Championship.
As long as Cardiff are as entertaining as they have been, some will be more than willing to turn a blind eye, but eventually their cavalier ways will surely catch up with them and start to lose its charm. Barry-Murphy is seemingly all in on this being the way we play and in fairness it worked in the first half yesterday, but the second half performance could have easily resulted in a far heavier defeat and that is a recurring theme on the road. Solidifying the defence without compromising the attack is easier said than done though, but balls to the wall, all out attacking does feel unsustainable and puts pressure on their unbeaten home record. If Cardiff want to balance their attacking prowess with their naivety, a compromise on their travels will be required.